|
A recent forum thread has opened the debate between Rook plus the odd pawn or two versus a pair of minor pieces. In general, one might tend to favour Rook and two pawns against the minor pieces (see, e.g. my annotated game id=sago vs id=ionadowman under the title "Great Snakes, Batman"). However, even with a pawn to make up the difference, the rook tends to find the two minor pieces too much of a handful. This game, however, had one, very unusual and rather strange feature that came to the aid of the rook. |
|
1. c4
|
English Opening... |

|
|
|
1... e5
|
Bremen System... |
3 comments
|
|
|
2. g3
|
Accelerated fianchetto. |
1 comment
|
|
|
2... d6 3. Bg2 f5
|
This is my favorite response to the English, a kind of "Dutch Defence" system that has in mind a K-side attack. |
2 comments
|
|
|
4. d4 Nf6
|
Black could instead play 4...e4, but 5.f3! inducing 5...exf3 6.Nxf3 is very good for White. |
1 comment
|
|
|
5. Nc3
|
Also playable is 5.dxe5 dxe5 6.Qxd8+ Kxd8, though the displacement of the King is of only minor inconvenience to Black. |
1 comment
|
|
|
5... Be7
|
Also to be considered were 5...c6 and 5...e4. |
1 comment
|
|
|
6. dxe5
|
(!?) Rather an odd decision, I find, given that Black doesn't have to retake on d8 with the King. |
2 comments
|
|
|
6... dxe5 7. Qxd8+ Bxd8
|
Retaking with the King might not be so very inconvenient, but the bishop recapture seemed preferable, all the same! |
2 comments
|
|
|
8. Nf3 Nc6
|
Preferable to the immediate 8...e4, which cedes White the d4-square. |
1 comment
|
|
|
9. O-O e4
|
Now that d4 is covered, this pawn advance seems to be indicated. |

|
|
|
10. Ng5
|
Possibly preferable was 10...Nd2, as on g5, this piece becomes a target. |

|
|
|
10... O-O 11. Rd1
|
In no position right now to challenge White's possession of the open file, Black elects to gain space on the K-side. |

|
|
|
11... h6 12. Nh3 Be6
|
The attack on c4 gains Black a bit of time... |

|
|
|
13. b3 g5
|
Placing a considerable constraint upon White's K-side, especially the h3-Knight. A good deal of Black's play in this game involves the motif of "constraint". |

|
|
|
14. f4
|
(!?) To prevent ...f4, or to induce the e.p. capture at f3? Black ignores it and places a bit of a clamp on White's K-side. |

|
|
|
14... g4
|
Playable indeed was 14...exf3 e.p. 15.exf3 Be7 with an OK game for Black. But I preferred to place White's K-side under constraint. |

|
|
|
15. Nf2 Be7
|
It has taken Black a while to get this bishop off d8, but that time has been put to good use. The game seems about even. |

|
|
|
16. Bb2 Rfd8
|
Development complete, now is the time to challenge White's tenure of the d-file. |

|
|
|
17. Nb5 Ne8
|
This odd defence for c7 came to mind owing to my reluctance, having brought the bishop of the d8-square, to have it return there (17...Rc8 18.Rxd8 Bxd8). Although White's b2-bishop can see clear to h8, it has no useful targets or squares on that diagonal. |

|
|
|