|
From | Message |
stalhandske 01-Feb-18, 11:18
|
NA moved 18. Ne5
New position Our move!
|
|
My vote is for 18...Rad8 as analysed previously.
|
|
18. Rad8
seems Ok, for me.
|
|
After last two weak moves Black's position is awful 18...Rad8 19. Rf2 Bb7 20. Rc2 and Black has no active play
|
stalhandske 01-Feb-18, 22:17
|
18. ....Rad8
for me, too
|
|
Rad8
also my next move
|
|
... Rad8
Yep This is the one...
|
|
WHY CAN'T WE PLAY NE4!?
|
stalhandske 03-Feb-18, 20:35
|
To me, 18. ...Ne4 is not bad either, but - for example - 18. .....Ne4 19. Bxe4 fxe4 20. Rf2 Nxe5 21. Bxe5 Qc6 results in a clear advantage for white
|
|
my idea is that after 20. Rf2 we play Nc4!i think that poses a few problems for white
|
stalhandske 03-Feb-18, 21:02
|
You must mean 20. ...Nc5 I think that is no good, because they would reply 21. b4! and quite a significant advantage.
|
|
Nc5 is right.b4 is only significant if they actually play Rf2, if u think that is certain then play 18 Nc5 instead of Ne4. the point is the move Rd8 leads to a lost game. either of the N moves gives them chances to go wrong and gives us a fighting chance of a draw,
|
stalhandske 03-Feb-18, 21:44
|
18. ....Nc5 was, I believe, discussed before. At least I have analysed it extensively. It most likely results in the beginning of a K-side attack by white, perhaps beginning with 19. g4 and later continuing with white advancing their g-pawn - all the way to g6 I won't go through the entire analysis, but at least acccording to that it is worse than 18. ...Rad8
|
|
o.k. i still think Nc5 is best, but its only academic as the majority favour the rook move. so be it.we can only do our best to hold out
|
5imon 04-Feb-18, 04:02
|
Deleted by 5imon on 04-Feb-18, 04:02.
|
|
18...Rad8 is our move
|
|
My comments are not so interesting, so ... I wish good luck to everybody
|
|
Cyrano
Your comments are interesting and always appreciated. If we're making the wrong moves then please tell us the right move before time is up. I can only make the move with the most votes.
|
|
19.Rf2 was played
Votes please.
|
stalhandske 05-Feb-18, 04:56
|
19. ...Nc5
What about 19. ...Nc5 to establish a replacement after Nfe4 and its exchange away by the bishop?
|
|
19... Nc5
Yes, indeed. We have to create some countergame
|
|
19...Bb7
I'm in favour in adding support to d5. The bishop isn't doing much on it's current square.
|
|
i am in favour of Nc5
|
|
Nc5
I also like Nc5 best
|
|
19 ... Bb7
I agree with Simon
|
|
19th move
the B in a6 prevents an immediate 20.b4 which could be rather anoying and which would prevent us to play a further Nc5 Bb7 can be play later. Nc5 has to be plaid now or never.
|
|
... can't argue with that, well said :-)
I bow down to that
|
|
Bb7
After that I have analyse the game more i also move my vote to BB7
|
|
vote count
19...Nc5 (stalhandske, ptitroque, nambam, thelitelixir) 19...Bb7 (5imon, tbre0022)
|
stalhandske 06-Feb-18, 20:22
|
After some more thinking and analysis, I change my preference to 19. ...Bb7 - it may be safer in the long run than 19. ...Nc5.
|
|