| From | Message | ||
|---|---|---|---|
|
dmaestro 18-Feb-22, 12:40 |
Keep On Dividing There are even serious questions about whether even efforts at civility when it’s clear we are too different are not just building a pressure cooker: unherd.com. But we know from studies these discussions only increase divisions. It’s past time to just segregate and move if needed live with our kind, admit we are just too different, and stop the pretense! |
||
|
BTW, who is this 'we' you keep referring to? |
||
|
dmaestro 18-Feb-22, 13:26 |
|
||
|
|
||
|
dmaestro 18-Feb-22, 18:29 |
There is more and more realization we are in conflict. Let it roll… |
||
|
DM |
||
|
dmaestro 19-Feb-22, 08:25 |
|
||
|
stalhandske 19-Feb-22, 08:29 |
Where does that lead? What should be done? I think that pertaining such an opinion is a pessimistic attitude that leads nowhere, except perhaps to violence. Is violence what you want? Do you think that will solve the problems of USA? Well, I don't. |
||
|
Stalh |
||
|
stalhandske 19-Feb-22, 08:34 |
Softaire |
||
|
|
||
|
dmaestro 19-Feb-22, 09:14 |
StalI can only look at existing data and extrapolate trends. The growing segregation and polarization is real. You see the dynamics in these clubs which are no different than we see in society. I can’t be optimistic. You see us as more alike than different, but look at the details on what happens on every issue. I think you really want us to work this out but taking all emotion out of it how would that work? There is a lot of research into our differences and they are real. |
||
|
stalhandske 19-Feb-22, 09:59 |
SoftaireI don't give an arse about your opinion of me. But I do about you lying about me in a public forum! I am not accusing you of this 'out of the blue'! I have written very specifically why you have been lying. You wrote that I have accused 'the right' of racism, which I have never done! Now, do you have a mirror? Have an honest look! |
||
|
stalhandske 19-Feb-22, 10:02 |
DmaestroI don't deny that. But I think the differences are actually much smaller than they are trumpeted to be on both sides. I have in the past shown concrete examples of this. At any rate, I think it is clear that you Americans MUST discuss these differences and reach one another, because the alternative is a never-ending disgrace for your country and - at worst - a cause of violence. |
||
|
dmaestro 19-Feb-22, 11:19 |
StalTechnically you are correct in theory. The divisions are amplified yea by those who gain from divisions and a large minority who are hyperpartisan—but we have no effective, engages centrist party or majority to work with and no agreement on what is factual and reliable info. As well as growing segregation and impatience. So a deeper dive shows why a majority now fear we are headed for conflict. The very fact all these conservatives push the narrative is all the Dems fault and deny they have any responsibility shows in practical terms why I believe I am correct about our divisions being too great in practice. |
||
|
|
||
|
dmaestro 19-Feb-22, 12:51 |
Stal To help understand the underlying dynamics: The country is far too divided into the 9 factions indicated above to unify. Biden made unforced errors like in Afghanistan and like Obama overpromised and repeated Obama’s mistake of foolishly underestimating partisanship and not adjusting his plans and priorities to the evolving situation, this time by assuming he could unify Democrats and moderates, get back to normal on the pandemic quickly with minimal damage despite huge divisions over the pandemic and his old personal relationships with Republicans mattered. The parties are divided internally as well. And the country faces complex dilemmas not solvable by the simple solutions of partisans so you always have divisions. Biden started at high 55%!approval but that is as good as it gets these days and Dems vastly overestimated their mandate so now the bill is due.‘I I’m done looking for common ground myself. The combination of divisive factors and divisive forces are too great IMO and I have all the evidence on why I need. Those who want to try are welcome to. |
||
|
dmaestro 19-Feb-22, 12:53 |
Thumper |
||
|
DMDetails? You mean anecdotal? I thought you were all about the controlled macro studies, and polls. |
||
|
stalhandske 20-Feb-22, 20:39 |
dmaestroWhat I don't understand is - if so - what you suggest to be the next step! |