|
|
| From | Message |
|---|
antagonistknight
19-Jun-09, 08:50
|
2 votes for Nc3
2 votes for exd4
So we need a tie breaker, unless someone wants to change thier vote.
|
|
 . . . |
|
Actual Unrated Game for Analysis
Fatcat2, would you consider allowing me to challenge you to an unrated game that follows this challenge for analytical purposes? The CM vs. KOH challenge has such a game for the same purpose. I must admit, I'm experiencing some difficulty following the game when the board is on one page and our arguments are on another. I would also like the capability of printing the board for even further analysis. [My memory isn't what it used to be. ]Thank you for your consider in this.
Jim
|
fatcat2
19-Jun-09, 10:56
|
Already there :-)
I think you've missed something - doji has already challenged me to an unrated, analysis game for exactly the same purpose, here:  game
|
tennesseehiker
19-Jun-09, 11:07
|
|
doji
19-Jun-09, 11:16
|
Jim
It is true what kendo-ka says: the theory gives Nc3 as the most common. To get things going, let us play Nc3....
So, this gives then 3 votes for Nc3, I will post the move.
|
doji
19-Jun-09, 11:21
|
3.Nc3
1. e4 e6
2. d4 d5
3. Nc3
To analyze the game:
game
|
fatcat2
19-Jun-09, 11:31
|
3...Bb4
My move is 3...Bb4
|
antagonistknight
19-Jun-09, 11:48
|
4. e5
The Winawer variation, looks like we get to play e5 after all. Next Black will most likely play c5 attacking our center.
|
doji
19-Jun-09, 12:02
|
4.e5
is also my vote, and I think you are right hbird1830!!
|
|
4. e5
I vote for e5 as well at this juncture.
|
kendo-ka
19-Jun-09, 17:39
|
This game is moving fast :)
I'll certainly go along with 4.e5
|
doji
20-Jun-09, 06:34
|
Deleted by doji on 21-Jun-09, 06:17.
|
fatcat2
20-Jun-09, 08:47
|
4...c5
My move is: 4...c5
|
doji
20-Jun-09, 15:37
|
I suggest
5. Bb5+ to be able to play 6. Nge2. If 5. Nge2 should be played, the bishop is stuck on f1 and we will have a "castling problem". If 5. Nc3 should be played, fatcat2 can play 5... Bxc3+; 6.bxc3 and then we have two pawns on the same row, I don't like this in this position. What do you bunch think?
|
kendo-ka
20-Jun-09, 16:39
|
Double pawns. :)
Judging by the gameknot database and the opening book I have, the move to make is a3. I have to say its probably the most likely move I'd make against this variation of the French Defence. Never fear doubled pawns sometimes they are a strength rather than a weakness.
Another move we could make is dxc5. But I'd rather go with a3
|
antagonistknight
20-Jun-09, 19:40
|
I agree with a3
|
|
5. a3
I, too, agree with a3. We need to rid of the pin posed by black's bishop.
|
doji
21-Jun-09, 06:17
|
Deleted by doji on 22-Jun-09, 00:27.
|
fatcat2
21-Jun-09, 06:19
|
5...Bxc3+
My move is 5...Bxc3+
|
|
Move 6. bxc3
I think we can all agree that bxc3 is our only viable play.
|
doji
21-Jun-09, 06:37
|
6. bxc3
Yep, we can, I think!
|
kendo-ka
21-Jun-09, 15:11
|
6.bxc3
Yup I vote for bxc3 too.
|
doji
22-Jun-09, 00:26
|
Deleted by doji on 24-Jun-09, 01:45.
|
fatcat2
22-Jun-09, 08:09
|
6...Ne7
My move is 6...Ne7.
|
kendo-ka
22-Jun-09, 10:10
|
7.Qg4
Not a move I would usually play since the queen is coming out early. However its not going to be chased away by a knight so it looks okay.
I'm voting Qg4
I would also be fine with Nf3 which is more my sort of move in this situation.
|
doji
23-Jun-09, 02:52
|
kendo-ka
I didn't see that one but sure have possibility's, good thinking. I vote for 7. Qg4 too!!
|
|
7. Qg4
I, too, vote for Qg4. I suspect fatcat2's next move will surely be O-O.
|
doji
24-Jun-09, 01:45
|
7. Qg4
1. e4 e6
2. d4 d5
3. Nc3 Bb4
4. e5 c5
5. a3 Bxc3+
6. bxc3 Ne7
7. Qg4
To analyze: game
Your move, fatcat2!
|
fatcat2
24-Jun-09, 01:51
|
Erm...
I think you've linked to the wrong board .
|
|
|
